Cold Email 101 – Part 5: Guide to Cold Email Follow Up

Welcome to the fifth and final day of our week-long series on creating and sending effective personalized cold emails. Today we’ll cover how to handle cold email follow ups, and tips on boosting response rates.

If you missed them, check out our previous posts on choosing the right tool for your cold email campaign, defining campaign goals, effective email copy and campaign set-up and execution. 

Post-Launch Campaign Management and Strategy

So you’ve launched an email campaign, work is done, right? Wrong.

Studies show that if you don’t respond to an email within 90 minutes the likelihood of getting a response drops drastically.

Handling replies is your top priority (yes, even the negative ones). Try calling positive replies as soon as you get the email back! If you don’t get a cold email follow up or call, set a task to follow up again in another day or so.

For a negative response, send a quick “thanks for your consideration” note — and let them know that if anything changes in the future that they should reach out to you.

A rejection is a great opportunity to share a piece of helpful content, so make sure you take advantage of it.

Most people think that their sales approach should be either cold calling or cold emailing. The truth is that the best practice is to do both. Having access to click and open rates data is a tremendous advantage when cold calling. These email tools give you insights into who knows your company, your name and what you do. These will be the warmest “cold calls” you’ll ever make. You should plan to call within 28-48 hours of the click or open.

Post-Campaign Metrics

After your campaign goes live, the metrics will provide important feedback for next steps. Open rates measure how good your subject line is, and replies measure how good your overall messaging and CTAs are. High open rate and low replies is an indication that you need to work on improving the CTA or the main value proposition of your message.

It’s important to track clicks, but beware of click-tracking features. Email service providers are catching on to click-tracking techniques, so including them in your messages can cause your emails to get caught up in spam filters.

“Always be testing” and use the data to your advantage.

A/B test your messaging whenever possible and follow the template that performs better for you. Each time you launch a new round of emails, replace the underperforming message with an updated version of the top performing version.

And lastly, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it! At a certain point, the metrics won’t budge any higher.

X number of leads = Y number of responses = Z number of opportunities = predictable revenue.

We hope you have enjoyed and benefitted from this five-part series. A personal, cold email follow up is a powerful tool for building a predictable revenue engine.

Cold Email 101 Index:

Part 1: Cold email marketing: Getting Started

Part 2: Defining your cold email marketing goals for maximum effectiveness.

Part 3: Learn how to write effective cold email copy.

Part 4: Discover how to set up a cold email campaign.

Free Starter Go-to-Market Toolkit

You may also like…

What is Go-to-Market Strategy? (Definition and Expert Tips)

What is Go-to-Market Strategy? (Definition and Expert Tips)

When searching for answers about how to develop your go-to-market strategy, there are thousands of articles that all generally provide the same broad answers. The challenge is that these go-to-market definitions tell entrepreneurs what going to market means, but they...

Successful SaaS Go-to-Market Strategy: A Case Study

Successful SaaS Go-to-Market Strategy: A Case Study

The founder of one of our portfolio companies had the idea to develop a tool that would enable schools to live stream sporting events at ESPN-level quality. By enabling schools to create such high quality productions, the schools would generate additional revenue by...

How to Map Out a Go-to-Market Strategy Framework

How to Map Out a Go-to-Market Strategy Framework

Think about the last time you went on a road trip (maybe it was just as recent as 2020 when many people chose cars over planes because of the pandemic). A lot of planning probably went into that trip about where to go, what to pack, how much money to bring for gas,...